Pages

Showing posts with label Oroville Dam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oroville Dam. Show all posts

Monday, April 29, 2019

Oroville Dam Failure Begins at the 908 Foot Lake Level According to The California Department of Water Resources





Information recently released by the California Division of Water Resources indicates that

1.  Oroville Dam failures will begin at the Emergency Spillway when lake levels reach 908 feet

2.  Oroville Dam failures will begin at the Main Spillway when lake levels reach 908 feet

3.  At a 899 ft lake level it only takes ~ 6 inches of rain in 21 hours to reach the 908 foot failure point

4.  No risk assessment has been performed on the unreinforced section of Emergency Spillway

5.  The Emergency Spillway no longer has capacity to be a redundancy for the Main Spillway

6.   The Emergency Spillway can now only handle a 100K CFS flow rate (was 450K CFS)

7.   The Main Spillway can now only handle a 269K CFS flow rate (was 301K CFS)

8.   Oroville Dam can no longer survive the Maximum Possible Flood ( an 1,800 year flood)

9.   Oroville Dam can not handle the Standard Project Flood when lake levels are above 848 feet

10. Global warming will make the 1,800 year Maximum Possible Flood occur more frequently 

11. Global warming will make the 440 year Standard Project Flood occur more frequently.

12. No risk mitigation work has been done on either the Spillway Gate or Hyatt Power House

13. Down stream levee failures will occur when release rates exceed 150K CFS,


The above data assumes that Oroville Dam will function 100% as claimed by the California Division of Water Resources. 

We question the veracity of 100%  dam operations for the following reasons


1. Even after massively reinforcing the top half of the Emergency Spillway, the hillside is so unstable that the Spillway flow rates had to be dropped by ~80%

2. Oroville Dam authorities have shown an inability to problem solve real time, as proven by their 2017 decision to use the Emergency Spillway despite an obviously eroding hillside, leading to issue 3

3. Oroville Dam authorities have an inability to recognize life threatening situations until the last possible moment, as evidenced by declaring an Emergency Evacuation after continuous claims of safety just moments prior.

3. In an Orwellian maneuver, Oroville Dam renamed the Emergency Spillway to the "Auxiliary Spillway" after its use resulted in a MASSIVE EMERGENCY EVACUATION; this renaming shows they WILL place and push a false appearance of safety above actual safety.

4. News organization were complicit in renaming the Emergency Spillway to the Auxiliary Spillway

5  During the recent low flow Main Spillway usage, we noticed an anomaly possibly affecting future Hyatt Power House operations. (more to follow)

6. Insufficient live Main Spillway testing has been done despite unusually high lake levels

7. Their Risk Analysis understates risks, as all risk events treated as separate and not interrelated.



Sources:










Sunday, March 5, 2017

Oroville Update: Survival Window Is Closing



Oroville Lake levels are rising
Spillway hillside at heightened risk of collapse
All water outflow has been stopped to ease collapse risk
Feather river  being deepened to mitigate risk of hillside collapse
Rain is forecast, zero outflow cannot be maintained for ever, hence the survival window is closing.

Any or all of the following situations we believe require IMMEDIATE risk mitigation actions

1. Hillside landslide blocking Feather river
2. Flooded Power House
3. Any use of Spillways combined with High Lake levels

Expected actions from the CA_DWR included:

1 Deepening the channel flowing around the debris dam
2 Lining the debris dam to prevent erosion from Power House flow
3 Stabilize eroded areas of the spillway hillside

The limited ability to carry out the above 3 actions is what is closing the survival window.

Sources:

http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Riverbanks-collapse-after-Oroville-Dam-spillway-10976144.php?t=a156df513f&cmpid=twitter-premium&cmpid=twitter-premium

ALERT! Oroville Dam is Lost if the Hyatt Power Plant Floods

http://cdec.water.ca.gov/cgi-progs/queryF?s=ORO&d=05-Mar-2017+16:25&span=12hours

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Oroville Dam Fault Mode Analysis: If the Hyatt Power Plant floods the Dam is lost



The primary constraint controlling risk mitigation decisions at Oroville Dam has been flooding of the Hyatt Power Plant; if the Power Plant floods the Dam is lost. The Power Plant is at risk because the failed spillway is cutting the hillside resulting in a debris dam and water back flow to the power house. Its for these reasons that the Emergency spillway was utilized.

Without that bit of insight the decision to use the Emergency spillway seems incredible stupid, as it obviously has a greater risk of head cutting erosion into the Dam than the damaged spillway. But at the time, it would seem the California Department of Water Resources thought the risk of hillside giving way at the primary spillway and flooding the PowerHouse was the primary risk.

Unfortunately now that the Emergency Spillway is at risk of catastrophic failure, there currently are no safe ways of regulating lake levels. That situation may change as the debris dam is pared down and the Power House regains the ability to spill water through the turbines.

If lake levels can be maintained solely using the turbine exhaust the Dam failure risk is greatly reduced. But as long as water discharges from the primary spill way remain outside of their designed path, loss of control of the Dam remain high; the only safety buffer being low lake levels.

Source Links:

https://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galleries/C0000OxvlgXg3yfg/G00003YCcmDTx48Y/I0000Ds3Gc4QPH_4/KG-oro-spillway-damage-12406-02-16-2017-jpg

https://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galleries/C0000OxvlgXg3yfg/G00003YCcmDTx48Y/I0000ADPF9o1e3ck/DK-Oro-Spillway-damage-4206-02-15-2017-jpg

https://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galleries/C0000OxvlgXg3yfg/G00003YCcmDTx48Y/I0000zVDjCL02CpI/DK-oro-spillway-damage-4639-02-27-2017-jpg

https://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galleries/C0000OxvlgXg3yfg/G00003YCcmDTx48Y/I0000BWQbsNHjqv0/DK-oro-spillway-damage-4474-02-27-2017-jpg

Lake Oroville Spillway February 27, 2017

Only Backup Generators Remain